For my Unit 2 proposal, I have decided to look at the arguments in response to the February 2010 decision by the FEI (International Equestrian Federation) to limit the use of a technique known as Rollkur in international Dressage Competitions. Rollkur (also known as Hyperflexion) is a training technique in which a horses head is carried behind the vertical. Many people find this technique to be unnatural and abusive to the horse, believing it contributes to severe neck bone and muscle injuries. The decision of the FEI was to ban Rollkur, which they defined as "flexion of the horse’s neck achieved through aggressive force, which is therefore unacceptable." However, they stated that the technique known as LDR (Low, Dreep and Round) was "Acceptable." This is interesting because LDR has the horses head in the same position as Rollkur, the only difference is the method used to achieve it - which is where the controversy starts. People weren't necessarily upset with the method used to achieve the positioning, it was the positioning itself that caused concern.
I intend to look for primary sources from Blogs and magazines. Mostly, I will use blogs created by horseback riders and those who enjoy following Dressage. Most individuals had something to say once the FEI's decision came out in February. Also, I have a Magazine called "Practical Horseman" that has a column from a highly respected U.S. horseman in direct response to the FEI's decision.
I chose this topic/event because it is one that I am truly interested in being an avid horseback rider. The people that are using Rollkur are not only casual riders that show at mid-level circuit, but also some of the most respected and accomplished riders in the world. You can click here to see a non-biased video that explains Rollkur/Hyperflexion and shows it being used in the training ring as well as the show ring.
Thursday, October 7, 2010
Tuesday, September 21, 2010
In Class: First Paragraph
The Rangers Ballpark in Arlington is one of my favorite places to go. I love everything about it, the sights, the sounds, and even the smells. There's nothing like walking in from the center field gates, walking past the Nolan Ryan statue and just looking out over the ballpark. The grass is the greenest grass you will ever see and it is complimented by the 40,000 dark green seats that surround it. My favorite time to be there is during batting practice, before the game even starts. It's early, so there isn't many other people there. It's almost like I have the whole stadium to myself. I sit down and listen to the sounds of baseball. Bat and ball, ball and glove. It's actually quite relaxing.
In Class: Peer Workshops
I have had lots of experience with in class peer workshops. My very first semester at TCU, I took the Freshman English course and it was set up in almost the exact same format. We did peer workshops with our first drafts. At first I was a little hesitant about having people read my paper, but after a while I became comfortable with it and eventually grew to enjoy it and find it very helpful. I found the advice and suggestions were extremely helpful and actually did help in making my paper better. Sometimes though, I felt as if my peers didn't really care to read or help. Those were the ones that made peer review a little annoying. However, I think there were far more people interested in actually revising papers than those that weren't. Overall, I think peer review is a helpful tool in revising a paper.
Thursday, September 16, 2010
In Class: Important Notes from my Notes
I need to clarify how I approximated the ratio of Ranger to Yankees fans. This seemed to be interesting to the people that read my paper.
I need to address the casual fan v.s serious fan. Discuss in detail, how I can tell them apart as well as make note of what may bring the casual fan to the ballpark. Obviously, we know why the serious fan goes to the game, but why does the casual fan go?
I also can discuss why the Yankees bring so much emotion to a baseball game and why they bring so many fans with them. I have learned from my notes that some people aren't familiar with the fact that the Yankees are one of the (if not the) most popular team in MLB. Being popular is what brings people to watch the Yankees, as there is no "Rivalry" between the Yankees and Rangers in particular. I need to note that the Yankees are a first place team right now, and that this game was more than just "another game". This series could be re-created in the post season, making it extremely important.
I need to address the casual fan v.s serious fan. Discuss in detail, how I can tell them apart as well as make note of what may bring the casual fan to the ballpark. Obviously, we know why the serious fan goes to the game, but why does the casual fan go?
I also can discuss why the Yankees bring so much emotion to a baseball game and why they bring so many fans with them. I have learned from my notes that some people aren't familiar with the fact that the Yankees are one of the (if not the) most popular team in MLB. Being popular is what brings people to watch the Yankees, as there is no "Rivalry" between the Yankees and Rangers in particular. I need to note that the Yankees are a first place team right now, and that this game was more than just "another game". This series could be re-created in the post season, making it extremely important.
In Class: Observation process
The observation process was what I expected. I have been to so many baseball games and have been to the Rangers Ballpark in Arlington so many times that I have seen almost everything there is to see. As usual, the Yankees fans were extremely annoying and rude. Fights broke out, and people were getting tossed (not the players) out of the stadium left and right. However, this is typical anytime the Yankees (or even Boston) comes to town. Also, many of their fans were not from New York. They were the typical bandwagon fans that only pick up a Yankees hat when they come to Texas. All of the highlights from the game were typical for a baseball game. The only odd thing about the game was that it went into extra innings, and we had a walk-off win. It was great, but I experienced almost the same thing a few ago at a Boston game.
The ballpark was packed, as I suspected it would be. Even though the game went past midnight, I don't think more than 10 people had left. Where there is usually free, or discounted parking it was $10. Overall, I was able to make many observations.
The ballpark was packed, as I suspected it would be. Even though the game went past midnight, I don't think more than 10 people had left. Where there is usually free, or discounted parking it was $10. Overall, I was able to make many observations.
Wednesday, September 15, 2010
Blog #4: Public Space Ethos, Pathos, and Logos
The Rangers Ballpark in Arlington has makes many arguments appealing to Ethos, Pathos, and Logos:
Ethos - Character, credibility
An appeal to Ethos is one of the most obvious arguments made at the ballpark. If you're not sitting on the first base side, you can easily spot three pennants displayed along a concrete wall. These pennants are from the years that the Rangers won the AL West division title - 1996, 1998, and 1999. These titles establish that the Rangers have had some success in past and establishes their credibility. However, many non-Rangers fans use these titles to make the exact opposite argument - That the Rangers aren't a very successful team, lowering their credibility as a ball club. Another Ethos argument in the constant presence of Nolan Ryan. For those who are not baseball fans, Nolan Ryan is one of the greatest pitchers in Major League Baseball. Video clips play during the game showing his 4,000th, 5,000th, and 5,714th career strikeouts - all in a Ranger Uniform. Having his presence at the Ballpark - historically and literally (he owns part of the Rangers and attends most games) significantly boosts the credibility of the Rangers.
Pathos - Emotion
If you are a hardcore baseball fan, it's hard not to experience emotion during a game, especially if it's extra innings at home against the New York Yankees. Since the game became tied in the bottom of the 8th, you could feel the tension in the air. Every single inning after that, it only grew. Every single time contact was made between bat and ball, there was a reaction, no matter if it was way foul or out to the warning track. However, the greatest emotion was felt when a Walk-off home run was hit in the bottom of the 13th by a Ranger Player. The excitement and energy felt was incredible. Every single Ranger fan walked away with a newfound sense of pride.
Logos - Logic
Baseball is a game of statistics. At all times, statistics for the game being played can be seen on the giant scoreboard above home run porch. These statistics can be obviously used to make arguments about a players performance during a game. With one quick glance, you would be able to tell that Elvis Andrus has gone 1-3 with a single to right field, two K's and a walk. While offensive statistics are usually reliable, pitching statistics can really mislead someone. For example: A pitcher can throw a no-hitter but get a loss at the same time. I could explain it, if you want!
Ethos - Character, credibility
An appeal to Ethos is one of the most obvious arguments made at the ballpark. If you're not sitting on the first base side, you can easily spot three pennants displayed along a concrete wall. These pennants are from the years that the Rangers won the AL West division title - 1996, 1998, and 1999. These titles establish that the Rangers have had some success in past and establishes their credibility. However, many non-Rangers fans use these titles to make the exact opposite argument - That the Rangers aren't a very successful team, lowering their credibility as a ball club. Another Ethos argument in the constant presence of Nolan Ryan. For those who are not baseball fans, Nolan Ryan is one of the greatest pitchers in Major League Baseball. Video clips play during the game showing his 4,000th, 5,000th, and 5,714th career strikeouts - all in a Ranger Uniform. Having his presence at the Ballpark - historically and literally (he owns part of the Rangers and attends most games) significantly boosts the credibility of the Rangers.
Pathos - Emotion
If you are a hardcore baseball fan, it's hard not to experience emotion during a game, especially if it's extra innings at home against the New York Yankees. Since the game became tied in the bottom of the 8th, you could feel the tension in the air. Every single inning after that, it only grew. Every single time contact was made between bat and ball, there was a reaction, no matter if it was way foul or out to the warning track. However, the greatest emotion was felt when a Walk-off home run was hit in the bottom of the 13th by a Ranger Player. The excitement and energy felt was incredible. Every single Ranger fan walked away with a newfound sense of pride.
Logos - Logic
Baseball is a game of statistics. At all times, statistics for the game being played can be seen on the giant scoreboard above home run porch. These statistics can be obviously used to make arguments about a players performance during a game. With one quick glance, you would be able to tell that Elvis Andrus has gone 1-3 with a single to right field, two K's and a walk. While offensive statistics are usually reliable, pitching statistics can really mislead someone. For example: A pitcher can throw a no-hitter but get a loss at the same time. I could explain it, if you want!
Tuesday, September 14, 2010
In Class: Logos Item
For my logos item, I am using the box score from a recent baseball game. A box score contains all of the information in statistical form from a baseball game. If you understand baseball, you will be able to almost recreate the entire game based upon the numbers in the box score. All of the happenings are based upon the observations made during the game.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)